Bibs Colour Natural Rubber vs. Itzy Ritzy Natural Rubber Newborn Pacifier

Here is the interesting thing about this matchup: both pacifiers use the exact same nipple material. Natural rubber latex, harvested from rubber trees, soft and flexible and slightly earthy-smelling. So this is not a silicone-vs-rubber debate. That simplifies things — and makes the differences that do exist more important.

The Bibs Colour comes from Denmark, has been a European staple for years, and is famous for its oversized round shield and cherry-shaped nipple. It looks vintage. It comes in about a million colors. Your Instagram feed is probably full of them.

The Itzy Ritzy Natural Rubber Pacifier is a US brand offering with a more compact shield and a slightly flatter symmetrical nipple. It is part of a larger ecosystem of matching baby accessories — clips, wipe cases, diaper bags — all in coordinated colors.

Your baby does not care about brand ecosystems or Scandinavian design heritage. But you might, and that is fine. Here is what actually differs between these two.

For more context on feeding schedules and pacifier introduction timing, check our baby feeding chart.

Since the material is the same, nipple shape becomes the single biggest functional difference between these two pacifiers.

The Bibs Colour uses a cherry-shaped nipple — round, bulbous at the tip, with a natural fullness that fills the mouth. This shape has been the European standard for decades. Babies who like to have something substantial to latch onto tend to take to it quickly. It sits in the mouth in any orientation, which means you do not need to worry about placing it "right side up."

The Itzy Ritzy uses a symmetrical, slightly flattened round nipple. It is still round (not orthodontic or flat), but it is a bit less bulbous than the Bibs cherry. Some lactation consultants like this shape for breastfed babies because the flatter profile may feel more familiar after nursing.

The honest reality: you cannot predict which shape your baby will prefer. Some babies latch onto the first thing offered and never look back. Others reject three pacifiers before accepting a fourth. If you have strong feelings about nipple shape, buy one of each and let your baby decide.

This is the most visible difference between the two pacifiers, and it matters more than you might think.

The Bibs Colour shield is large, round, and lightweight. It was designed to sit well away from the baby's nose, which improves breathing during use. The ventilation holes prevent moisture and drool from pooling against the skin. Despite looking big, it weighs almost nothing — the polypropylene plastic is remarkably light. First-time parents sometimes think it looks too big for a newborn, but babies adjust to it quickly.

The Itzy Ritzy shield is more compact and modern-looking. It sits closer to the face and has a lower visual profile. Some parents prefer this for newborns because it looks proportional to a tiny face. The ventilation holes are present here too, so airflow is not a concern.

Neither shield design is inherently better. The Bibs shield does a better job keeping the pacifier away from the nose, which can matter for babies who are congested or stuffy. The Itzy Ritzy shield is less bulky, which some babies (and parents) prefer visually and practically — it fits more easily into pockets and pacifier cases.

Because both pacifiers use natural rubber nipples, the durability story is nearly identical.

Both nipples will start to show wear after 3 to 4 weeks of regular use. The rubber absorbs trace amounts of moisture and saliva over time, causing it to swell slightly, become tacky, and eventually discolor. This is normal for natural rubber and is not a defect — it is just the material doing what rubber does.

Cleaning is the same for both:

• Boil for 5 minutes before first use and periodically afterward.
• Hand-wash with warm soapy water for daily cleaning.
• Do not put either in the dishwasher. Natural rubber does not handle high-heat dishwasher cycles well.
• Inspect before every use. Pull gently on the nipple and look for cracks, tears, stickiness, or swelling. Replace immediately if anything looks off.

One small note: because the Bibs shield is slightly simpler in its joint design, some parents find it marginally easier to clean around the nipple-shield connection. But the difference is minimal. Both require the same level of attention.

Avoid leaving either pacifier in direct sunlight for extended periods. UV light accelerates rubber degradation. That pacifier clipped to the stroller canopy in July? It will not last its full three weeks.

Neither pacifier is expensive in absolute terms, but the Bibs Colour does come in a bit cheaper — roughly $4–$5.50 per pacifier in multi-packs versus $5–$7 per pacifier for the Itzy Ritzy.

Over six months, that gap is modest but real. If you are rotating through two pacifiers at a time and replacing every 3 to 4 weeks, you might spend around $50–$70 on Bibs versus $60–$85 on Itzy Ritzy over the same period. Not a dramatic difference, but every dollar counts in the first year.

The Bibs 4-pack bundles are where the value shows up most clearly. Buying four at once drops the per-unit cost noticeably, and you will want backups anyway. Pacifiers have a way of ending up under the crib, inside the car seat, and occasionally in the dog's mouth.

A few ways to save on either brand:

• Buy multi-packs whenever they are available. The per-unit savings are real.
• Watch for seasonal sales. Both brands discount during Prime Day, Black Friday, and registry completion events.
• Do not over-sterilize. Once your baby is past the first month, warm soapy water is fine for routine cleaning. Reserve boiling for floor drops and public-place incidents. Less heat means the rubber lasts a bit longer.

The Bibs Colour Pacifier (~$5/pacifier in a 2-pack) is the pick if you want the widest color range, a classic cherry-shaped nipple, and an oversized shield that has been proven in European nurseries for years. Grab a 4-pack to get the best per-unit price and to always have a clean one ready.

The Itzy Ritzy Pacifier (~$6/pacifier in a 2-pack) is the pick if you prefer a flatter nipple profile, a compact shield, and the option to match your pacifier with coordinated clips and accessories. It is a well-made pacifier from a brand that pays attention to the small details.

Since both use the same nipple material, buying one of each to test is a smart move. Your baby will tell you which shape and shield they prefer within about thirty seconds of trying each one.

tinylog earns a small commission on purchases made through these links, at no cost to you.

The Bibs Colour and Itzy Ritzy Natural Rubber Pacifier are more alike than different. Same nipple material, same replacement schedule, same cleaning routine. The real differences come down to nipple shape, shield size, color options, and price.

Bibs Colour wins on color variety, per-unit cost, shield design (if you want oversized), and the fuller cherry-shaped nipple. It is the pacifier that has been soothing European babies since before natural rubber became trendy in the US.

Itzy Ritzy wins on compact shield design, a flatter nipple profile that some breastfed babies prefer, coordinated accessories, and availability through US retailers. It is the more modern-looking option.

The truth is that both are good pacifiers, and the one that works is the one your baby accepts. If your first pick gets spit across the room, do not take it personally — just try the other one. That is basically the first year of parenthood in a nutshell: try things, observe, adjust, repeat.

If you are logging feeds and tracking fussy periods — which is incredibly helpful for figuring out what soothes your baby — tinylog makes it easy to record everything in one place and spot the patterns you would otherwise miss.

• Baby Feeding Chart — How much your baby should eat by age
• Breastfeeding Positions — Find the hold that works for you and your baby
• Baby Witching Hour — Why evenings are rough and what actually helps
• Newborn Essentials Checklist — What you actually need before baby arrives

• BIBSworld.com. "BIBS Colour — Product Information and Materials." 2026.
• ItzyRitzy.com. "Natural Rubber Pacifiers — Product Information." 2026.
• American Academy of Pediatrics. "Pacifiers: Satisfying Your Baby's Needs." healthychildren.org, 2025.
• American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry. "Policy on Pacifiers." aapd.org, 2024.
• Sexton S, Natale R. "Risks and Benefits of Pacifiers." American Family Physician. 2009;79(8):681-685.
• FDA.gov. "Latex in Medical Devices — Information for Consumers." US Food and Drug Administration, 2024.

This guide is for informational purposes only. Both pacifiers contain natural rubber latex — if your baby or family has a latex allergy, choose a silicone pacifier instead. If your baby develops a rash, swelling, or irritation around the mouth, discontinue use and consult your pediatrician.