Boudreaux's Butt Paste vs. Tubby Todd All Over Ointment

Boudreaux's Butt Paste and Tubby Todd All Over Ointment end up in the same comparison because parents shopping for baby skin care often weigh them against each other. But these two products are trying to solve different problems, and understanding that distinction is the key to picking the right one.

Boudreaux's Butt Paste Original is a diaper rash cream, plain and simple. It contains 16% zinc oxide in a smooth, spreadable base of beeswax, castor oil, and Peruvian balsam. It creates a moisture barrier on your baby's bottom that keeps wetness and irritants from reaching the skin. It is designed for the diaper area, used at every change, and it does that job reliably.

Tubby Todd All Over Ointment is a multi-purpose skin balm made with plant butters, botanical oils, zinc oxide, and colloidal oatmeal. Parents reach for it when their baby has eczema flare-ups, cradle cap, dry cheeks, rough patches on arms and legs, and yes — diaper rash too. It is formulated to nourish and soothe skin anywhere on the body, not just under the diaper.

If you are looking for a workhorse diaper cream, Boudreaux's has been earning that trust for decades. If your baby's skin needs are broader than the diaper area, Tubby Todd was built for exactly that.

The ingredient lists tell you everything about what each product is trying to do.

Boudreaux's Butt Paste is built around 16% zinc oxide — a proven, FDA-recognized skin protectant that creates a physical barrier on the skin. The supporting ingredients include Peruvian balsam (a natural resin with mild antiseptic properties), beeswax (adds structure and skin protection), castor oil (emollient), and mineral oil. Together, they form a paste that goes on smooth, stays in place, and shields irritated diaper skin from further moisture damage.

Tubby Todd All Over Ointment takes a different path. It uses zinc oxide alongside colloidal oatmeal (a well-studied skin soother), shea butter, avocado oil, sunflower seed oil, jojoba oil, and rosemary extract. These plant-based ingredients provide fatty acids the skin can absorb, anti-inflammatory support from the oatmeal and zinc, and deep moisturizing from the butter and oil blend. The formula is designed to feed the skin, not just cover it.

In practical terms, Boudreaux's creates a barrier that sits on top of the skin. Tubby Todd absorbs into the skin and works from the outside in. Both approaches have their place — the right one depends on what your baby's skin needs at the moment.

For straightforward diaper rash prevention and treatment, Boudreaux's Butt Paste is hard to argue with. It was literally named for this purpose, and it has been a go-to recommendation from pediatricians and experienced parents for years.

The 16% zinc oxide concentration is strong enough to protect against everyday moisture irritation without being so heavy that it turns into a wrestling match at every diaper change. The beeswax and castor oil base spreads smoothly — a meaningful advantage over thicker, paste-like alternatives that fight you on application. And it comes off with standard baby wipes, which matters at 3 AM when you are half asleep.

Tubby Todd can handle diaper rash too, thanks to the zinc oxide in its formula. Many parents use it in the diaper area with good results. But Boudreaux's is purpose-built for this job. The formulation, the texture, the application — everything about it is optimized for quick diaper changes and consistent barrier protection.

If diaper rash prevention is your primary concern and your baby's skin is otherwise healthy, Boudreaux's is the more efficient choice for the job.

If your baby's skin challenges extend beyond the diaper area, this is where Tubby Todd earns its following.

The combination of colloidal oatmeal, zinc oxide, and plant-based oils hits multiple aspects of conditions like eczema and cradle cap. Colloidal oatmeal soothes itching and calms inflammation. Zinc oxide reduces redness. Shea butter and avocado oil deliver moisture deep into dry, flaky skin. Parents who have cycled through a shelf full of lotions and creams often describe Tubby Todd as the product that finally made a visible difference.

For cradle cap specifically, the blend of plant oils helps soften and loosen the crusty, flaky scales on baby's scalp, while the zinc oxide calms the underlying irritation. Many parents apply it before bath time, let it sit, then gently brush the scales away.

Boudreaux's Butt Paste is not designed for these broader skin concerns. You could technically apply it to a dry patch, but you would be using a diaper cream off-label and missing out on the nourishing ingredients that make Tubby Todd effective for whole-body skin care.

If your baby deals with recurring eczema, persistent dry patches, or cradle cap, Tubby Todd gives you a single jar that addresses all of it. That versatility is a real advantage for families managing multiple skin issues.

The cost gap between these two products is significant. Boudreaux's Butt Paste runs about $1.06–$2.25 per ounce depending on the size you buy. Tubby Todd All Over Ointment runs $5.33–$8.00 per ounce — roughly three to six times more expensive.

Over a month, that difference is real. A family using Boudreaux's daily might spend $5–$14 per month. A family relying on Tubby Todd for daily whole-body skin care could spend $14–$36 per month. Over a year, the gap can easily reach $100–$250.

That said, the comparison is not entirely apples to apples. Boudreaux's is a single-purpose diaper cream. If you are using Tubby Todd to replace separate products for eczema, cradle cap, dry patches, and diaper rash, the per-product math starts to look more reasonable. One jar of Tubby Todd replacing three or four specialty products can actually save money in certain situations.

A few ways to manage the cost:

• Use Boudreaux's for the diaper area and Tubby Todd only for problem skin elsewhere — this is the most budget-friendly approach
• Buy Tubby Todd's 6 oz jar instead of the 2 oz — the per-ounce cost drops meaningfully
• Watch for bundle deals on TubbyTodd.com and subscribe for recurring discounts
• Stock up on Boudreaux's 16 oz tub from Amazon or warehouse clubs for the best per-ounce price

If you need a reliable, affordable diaper rash cream for everyday use, Boudreaux's Butt Paste (~$1.75/oz in the 4 oz tube, less in the 16 oz tub) is one of the most trusted names in the diaper caddy. The smooth 16% zinc oxide formula goes on fast, comes off without a fight, and keeps your baby's bottom protected change after change. The 16 oz tub is a great value for families who cream up at every change.

If your baby has eczema, cradle cap, dry patches, or skin issues that go beyond the diaper area, Tubby Todd All Over Ointment (~$5.33–$8.00/oz depending on size) is worth the investment — the plant-based formula with colloidal oatmeal and zinc oxide tackles multiple skin concerns in a single jar, and it has a devoted following among parents whose babies struggle with stubborn skin issues.

Our honest take: these products complement each other more than they compete. Boudreaux's for the diaper area, Tubby Todd for everything else. Many parents end up keeping both in the nursery and reach for whichever one the moment calls for.

tinylog earns a small commission on purchases made through these links, at no cost to you.

Boudreaux's Butt Paste and Tubby Todd All Over Ointment are both well-made products, but they are built for different jobs.

Boudreaux's Butt Paste is a focused diaper rash cream that does one thing and does it well. The 16% zinc oxide formula in a smooth, spreadable base makes it a reliable daily workhorse for the diaper area. It is affordable, widely available, and trusted by parents and pediatricians alike. If diaper rash prevention is what you need, it is hard to beat.

Tubby Todd All Over Ointment is a versatile skin balm that tackles eczema, cradle cap, dry patches, and diaper rash with a plant-based, nourishing formula. It costs significantly more, but for families dealing with skin issues beyond the diaper area, the ability to address multiple concerns with one product is a genuine advantage. The colloidal oatmeal and botanical oil blend has won over parents who had nearly given up on finding something that worked.

The smartest move for most families is not picking one or the other — it is using both where they are strongest. Boudreaux's handles the diaper area with speed and efficiency. Tubby Todd handles the rest of your baby's skin with nourishing, plant-based care.

If you are testing new products on your baby's skin, tracking reactions and patterns in tinylog can help you figure out what is working. A week of logged data tells you more than guessing ever will.

• Baby Diaper Rash — Causes, treatment, and when to call your doctor
• Desitin vs. Boudreaux's Butt Paste — Two zinc oxide creams compared head to head
• Tubby Todd vs. Aquaphor Baby Healing Ointment — Plant-based balm vs. petroleum-based ointment
• Baby Eczema — How to manage your baby's eczema at home

• BoudreauxsButtPaste.com. "Boudreaux's Butt Paste Original Diaper Rash Ointment — Product Information." 2026.
• TubbyTodd.com. "All Over Ointment — Product Information and Ingredient List." 2026.
• American Academy of Pediatrics. "Diaper Rash." HealthyChildren.org, 2025.
• National Eczema Association. "Emollients and Moisturizers for Eczema." nationaleczema.org.
• Mayo Clinic. "Diaper Rash — Diagnosis and Treatment." mayoclinic.org, 2025.
• Healthline Parenthood. "Best Diaper Rash Creams and Baby Ointments." healthline.com, 2026.
• Consumer Reports. "Best Diaper Rash Creams From Our Evaluation." consumerreports.org, 2026.

This guide is for informational purposes only and is not medical advice. Every baby's skin is different. If your baby develops a persistent or worsening rash that does not respond to over-the-counter treatment, consult your pediatrician.