Tommee Tippee Night Time Glow vs. Itzy Ritzy Natural Rubber Pacifier

The Tommee Tippee Night Time Glow and the Itzy Ritzy Natural Rubber Pacifier both do the same basic job — they soothe your baby. But they approach it from completely different angles.

Tommee Tippee built theirs around a very specific problem: you cannot find the pacifier at 3 AM and you refuse to turn on the light because you know that will fully wake the baby. The glow-in-the-dark shield charges under any light source and stays visible for hours. The nipple itself is medical-grade silicone with a symmetrical shape designed to sit naturally in the mouth.

Itzy Ritzy focused on materials and feel. Their pacifier is 100% natural rubber with a cherry-shaped nipple that closely mimics the breast. It is softer and more flexible than silicone, which can matter for breastfed babies transitioning between nursing and a pacifier.

Both are BPA-free, designed for 0–6 months, and built as one-piece construction. Your baby will not care about any of this — they will either accept it or spit it across the room. But knowing the differences helps you make a smarter first purchase.

For more on feeding schedules and tracking your newborn's intake, check out our baby feeding chart.

Yes. Full stop.

If you have not experienced the specific frustration of patting around a dark crib at 2 AM trying to find a clear silicone pacifier on a white sheet, this feature might seem gimmicky. It is not. The Tommee Tippee Night Time Glow shield absorbs ambient light — daylight, a lamp, even a phone screen — and emits a soft glow for hours afterward.

You do not need to do anything special. Just leave it near a light source during the day and it charges itself. At night, you can spot it immediately on the mattress, the floor, or wedged between the crib bars.

The Itzy Ritzy does not have this feature. If nighttime pacifier retrieval is a regular part of your life right now, the Tommee Tippee solves that problem directly. If your baby mostly uses a pacifier during the day or you already have a dim nightlight that works fine, it matters less.

This is the fundamental difference between these two pacifiers, and it affects everything from how they feel in your baby's mouth to how you clean them.

Silicone (Tommee Tippee) is a synthetic polymer. It is odorless, tasteless, firm, and holds its shape well. You can boil it, dishwasher it, microwave it in a sterilizer, and it comes back looking exactly the same. It does not absorb flavors or smells. The trade-off is that it is firmer than rubber — some babies notice.

Natural rubber (Itzy Ritzy) comes from rubber tree sap. It is softer, more flexible, warmer to the touch, and has a texture that some babies prefer — especially breastfed babies who are used to the feel of skin. The trade-off is durability: rubber degrades faster, can become sticky or discolored, cannot handle repeated high heat, and needs to be replaced every four weeks.

Plenty of parents keep both types on hand. There is no wrong answer here — just different priorities.

How easy a pacifier is to clean matters more than you think it will before the baby arrives. After the baby arrives, it matters a lot.

Tommee Tippee Night Time Glow can be cleaned in the dishwasher (top rack), boiled, sterilized in the microwave, or washed with soap and water. Silicone handles all of it. The glow-in-the-dark material is embedded in the shield, so cleaning does not affect the glow function. Simple.

Itzy Ritzy Natural Rubber must be hand washed with warm water and mild soap. No dishwasher. No microwave sterilizer. No boiling after that initial first-use sterilization. High heat breaks down natural rubber, causing it to warp, get sticky, or degrade.

If you are someone who wants to sterilize pacifiers regularly — and honestly, you probably should in the first few months — the Tommee Tippee fits into that routine without friction. The Itzy Ritzy works fine with hand washing, but it is an extra step in a life that already has too many steps.

One more practical note: natural rubber can develop a faint smell over time if not dried thoroughly. Silicone stays odorless indefinitely. Small thing, but it is worth knowing.

Both pacifiers come in 2-packs at similar price points — roughly $6 to $10. The per-pacifier cost is close enough that a single purchase feels about the same.

The difference shows up over time. The Tommee Tippee silicone lasts 4–8 weeks before needing replacement. The Itzy Ritzy natural rubber needs replacing every 4 weeks. Over six months of use, the Itzy Ritzy costs noticeably more — you are buying roughly twice as many packs.

If budget is tight, the Tommee Tippee is the more economical choice. If you value the natural rubber feel and the cost difference does not bother you, the Itzy Ritzy is still a reasonable buy. Just factor in the ongoing replacement expense.

Both are available at Amazon, Target, and most baby retailers. Prices shift regularly, so it is worth checking a couple stores before ordering.

The Tommee Tippee Night Time Glow (~$3–$4.50/pacifier in the 2-pack) is the practical pick for nighttime parents. Glow-in-the-dark shield, dishwasher-safe silicone, and a symmetrical nipple that most babies accept. If you are doing multiple nighttime wake-ups and tired of fumbling in the dark, this one earns its spot on the nightstand. Available at Amazon, Target, and Walmart.

The Itzy Ritzy Pacifier (~$3.50–$5/pacifier in the 2-pack) is the natural-material choice with a breast-mimicking cherry shape and beautiful color options. Breastfed babies often latch onto the softer rubber nipple quickly. Just plan on hand washing and monthly replacement.

Buying one pack of each is honestly the smartest move. Your baby will tell you which one wins in about five seconds flat.

tinylog earns a small commission on purchases made through these links, at no cost to you.

The Tommee Tippee Night Time Glow and Itzy Ritzy Natural Rubber Pacifier are both well-designed products that solve different problems.

Tommee Tippee Night Time Glow wins on nighttime convenience (that glow feature is no joke), cleaning ease, durability, and slightly lower long-term cost. It is the low-maintenance, high-utility option.

Itzy Ritzy Natural Rubber wins on softness, natural materials, breast-mimicking nipple shape, and aesthetics. It is the more natural, more beautiful option — and some breastfed babies simply prefer the feel of rubber.

For most families, buying one pack of each and running a real-world test is the best approach. The pacifier your baby actually keeps in their mouth is the right pacifier. Everything else is just features on a box.

There is no rule against using both. Some parents use the Tommee Tippee at night (where the glow is clutch) and the Itzy Ritzy during the day (where the softer feel and cute colors shine). Whatever works, works.

If you are tracking your baby's feeding and soothing patterns — and you should, especially in the early weeks — tinylog makes it easy to log everything and see what is working over time.

• Baby Feeding Chart — How much your baby should eat by age
• 1-Month-Old Sleep Schedule — What to expect for sleep in the first month
• Breastfeeding Basics — Getting started with nursing your newborn
• Baby Gas — Causes, relief, and when to call your pediatrician

• TommeeTippee.com. "Night Time Glow Pacifier — Product Information." 2026.
• ItzyRitzy.com. "Natural Rubber Pacifier 0–6M — Product Information." 2026.
• Amazon.com. "Tommee Tippee Breast-Like Night Time Pacifier — Customer Reviews." 2026.
• Amazon.com. "Itzy Ritzy Natural Rubber Newborn Pacifiers — Customer Reviews." 2026.
• Mommyhood101. "The Best Pacifiers of 2026, Tested & Reviewed." mommyhood101.com.
• American Academy of Pediatrics. "Pacifier Use and SIDS Risk Reduction." aap.org.

This guide is for informational purposes only. Pacifier choice is a personal preference based on your baby's individual needs. If your baby develops persistent oral irritation or skin reactions with any pacifier, consult your pediatrician.