GUIDE
WaterWipes vs. Honest Company Baby Wipes
Both are solid choices for parents who want cleaner ingredients. WaterWipes wins on minimal ingredients (99.9% water). Honest Company wins on texture, thickness, and plant-based materials. Cost is comparable in bulk.
WaterWipes and Honest Company Baby Wipes sit at the premium end of the baby wipe market, and both attract parents who read ingredient labels. WaterWipes built its brand on extreme simplicity — just water and a drop of fruit extract. Honest Company appeals to parents who want plant-based, sustainably sourced wipes with a thicker, quilted texture. For most babies, either will get the job done without irritation.
Free trial • Log changes, blowouts, and rashes
Two Premium Wipes, Two Very Different Approaches
WaterWipes and Honest Company Baby Wipes both market themselves to ingredient-conscious parents — but they solve the problem in opposite ways.
WaterWipes took the subtraction approach. Strip everything out. What's left is 99.9% purified water and a trace of grapefruit seed extract. That's it. No preservatives, no lotions, no botanical blends. The idea is simple: the fewer things touching your baby's skin, the lower the chance of a reaction.
Honest Company took the addition approach. Start with a plant-based cloth, then add gentle botanical ingredients like chamomile and aloe that are known to soothe skin. Make the wipe thick enough to handle real messes. Certify the whole thing through EPA Safer Choice.
Both approaches work. Which one is right for your family depends on your baby's skin, your values around sustainability, and how you feel about wipe thickness during a 3 AM blowout.
For more on tracking your baby's output patterns, see our baby feeding chart.
| Feature | WaterWipes Original | Honest Company Baby Wipes | What It Means |
|---|---|---|---|
| Manufacturer | WaterWipes (Ireland) | The Honest Company (USA) | WaterWipes is an Irish company. Honest Company was co-founded by Jessica Alba. |
| Key ingredients | 99.9% purified water, 0.1% grapefruit seed extract | Plant-based cloth with botanical extracts (chamomile, aloe) | WaterWipes wins on simplicity. Honest wins on added botanical benefits. |
| Fragrance | None | None | Tie. Both are completely fragrance-free. |
| Cloth material | Viscose (wood-based), thin and soft | Plant-based, quilted and thicker | Honest wipes are noticeably thicker and more textured. WaterWipes are softer and thinner. |
| Moisture level | Very wet — dripping when pulled from pack | Moderately wet — damp but not dripping | WaterWipes are among the wettest wipes on the market. Some parents love this; others find it excessive. |
| Durability | Tears more easily under pressure | Holds up well during tough cleanups | Honest wipes are more durable. WaterWipes can tear during stubborn messes. |
| Shelf life once opened | ~4 weeks (no chemical preservatives) | Standard shelf life | WaterWipes dry out faster. Reseal the pack tightly after every use. |
| Hypoallergenic | Yes — dermatologist-approved | Yes — dermatologist-tested | Tie. Both are designed for sensitive baby skin. |
| Certifications | National Eczema Association accepted | EPA Safer Choice certified, USDA BioPreferred | Both carry credible third-party certifications. Different focus areas. |
| Sustainability | Biodegradable option available, plastic-free packaging in some lines | Plant-based cloth, sustainably sourced materials | Both brands are making moves toward sustainability. Honest edges out with plant-based materials across its full line. |
| Wipes per pack | 60 per pack (typical) | 72 per pack (typical) | Honest packs include more wipes per unit. Compare per-wipe cost, not per-pack price. |
Ingredients: Simplicity vs. Botanicals
This is the core difference between these two wipes, and it comes down to a philosophical choice.
WaterWipes contain two ingredients. Purified water and grapefruit seed extract. The grapefruit seed extract acts as a mild skin conditioner — not a preservative in the traditional sense. This is why WaterWipes have a shorter shelf life once opened and why they are accepted by the National Eczema Association.
Honest Company wipes contain a longer ingredient list, but every ingredient is plant-derived and the formula is free from chlorine processing, fragrances, parabens, phthalates, and synthetic preservatives. The addition of chamomile and aloe provides mild soothing properties that some parents appreciate for routine diaper area care.
If your baby has confirmed eczema or highly reactive skin, WaterWipes are the more conservative choice simply because there are fewer variables. If your baby's skin is generally healthy and you want a wipe that does a bit more, Honest Company's botanical blend is perfectly safe for the vast majority of babies.
Thickness and Texture: The Practical Difference
On paper, both are baby wipes. In your hand at 2 AM during a code-orange diaper situation, thickness matters.
WaterWipes are thin and very wet. They feel almost like a damp cloth. They are gentle and glide across skin without friction, which is great for routine wet diaper changes and for wiping faces and hands. But they can tear during aggressive cleaning of sticky, stubborn messes. You may find yourself using two or three wipes where one thicker wipe would do.
Honest Company wipes are quilted and sturdy. The plant-based cloth has a textured surface that grips and cleans more effectively with each pass. They hold up during the worst blowouts without falling apart in your hand. The tradeoff is that they feel slightly less delicate on skin.
Many parents end up keeping both: WaterWipes for gentle newborn skin and daily changes, Honest Company wipes for diaper bag duty and bigger messes.
tinylog tracks diapers so you can spot patterns.
Log wet and dirty diapers, note blowouts and rashes, track output over days and weeks. Bring the data to your next pediatrician visit.
Moisture and Shelf Life
WaterWipes are noticeably wetter than Honest Company wipes — or most other wipes on the market, for that matter. When you pull one from the pack, it drips. This extreme moisture is part of the appeal: you are essentially cleaning your baby with purified water on a soft cloth.
The downside is practical. Because WaterWipes rely on grapefruit seed extract rather than synthetic preservatives, they dry out faster once the pack is opened. Plan to use an opened pack within about four weeks. In dry climates or heated nurseries, they can dry out even faster. A good wipe dispenser with a tight seal helps.
Honest Company wipes maintain their moisture level more consistently over time. They are damp without being drenched, and they hold up well even if a pack sits in your diaper bag for a few weeks.
| Product | Typical Price | Cost Per Wipe | Monthly Estimate |
|---|---|---|---|
| WaterWipes Original (60-ct, single pack) | $5.49–$6.99 | ~$0.09–$0.12 | ~$36–$48 |
| Honest Company Baby Wipes (72-ct, single pack) | $4.99–$6.49 | ~$0.07–$0.09 | ~$28–$36 |
| WaterWipes Original (720-ct, bulk box) | $38–$46 | ~$0.05–$0.06 | ~$20–$24 |
| Honest Company Baby Wipes (576-ct, bulk box) | $26–$34 | ~$0.05–$0.06 | ~$20–$24 |
Price: Buy in Bulk Either Way
At single-pack prices, both WaterWipes and Honest Company wipes are premium-priced compared to store brands. You will pay roughly $0.07–$0.12 per wipe depending on the brand and pack size.
The good news: bulk pricing closes the gap dramatically. Both brands offer large boxes through Amazon, Target, and warehouse clubs that bring the per-wipe cost down to $0.05–$0.06 — which is competitive with many mid-tier wipes.
Smart ways to save:
- Subscribe and save. Amazon, Target Circle, and Walmart+ all offer 5–15% off recurring wipe deliveries.
- Buy the big box. The per-wipe cost drops 30–50% when you buy 500+ count boxes.
- Stack sales with subscriptions. Both brands run periodic promotions that stack with subscription discounts.
- Watch for registry completion discounts. If you are still building a baby registry, both brands are commonly available through Amazon and Target registries with completion coupons.
At bulk pricing, the cost difference between these two brands is negligible. Pick the one your baby's skin prefers.
Choose WaterWipes If
- Your baby has eczema, extremely sensitive skin, or reacts to almost everything
- You want the absolute fewest ingredients possible touching your baby's skin
- You prefer a very wet wipe for gentle, no-friction cleaning
- Your baby is a newborn and you want something as close to cotton balls and water as possible
- Your pediatrician or dermatologist recommended a minimal-ingredient wipe
Choose Honest Company Baby Wipes If
- You want a thicker, more durable wipe that handles messy blowouts without tearing
- Sustainability and plant-based materials are priorities for your family
- You prefer a wipe that is damp but not dripping wet
- You want botanical ingredients like chamomile and aloe for soothing
- You are looking for better per-wipe value without going to a budget brand
- You need wipes that hold up well in a diaper bag for on-the-go changes
Where to Buy
If minimal ingredients are your priority, WaterWipes Original Baby Wipes (~$0.05–$0.06/wipe in bulk) are hard to beat — 99.9% water, accepted by the National Eczema Association, and trusted by parents of babies with the most sensitive skin. The 720-count box on Amazon is the best value.
If you want a thicker, plant-based wipe with botanical soothing ingredients, Honest Company Baby Wipes (~$0.05–$0.06/wipe in bulk) deliver durability, sustainability certifications, and a chamomile-aloe formula that holds up during the messiest changes. The 576-count box is the sweet spot for value.
Our honest advice: if your baby has reactive skin, start with WaterWipes. If skin sensitivity is not a concern, try both and see which texture and moisture level you prefer. There is no wrong answer here.
tinylog earns a small commission on purchases made through these links, at no cost to you.
The Bottom Line
WaterWipes and Honest Company Baby Wipes are both excellent choices for parents who want to avoid unnecessary chemicals on their baby's skin. The differences are real but come down to priorities:
WaterWipes win on ingredient simplicity, extreme moisture, and suitability for the most sensitive or eczema-prone skin. They are the closest thing to cleaning your baby with just water.
Honest Company Baby Wipes win on thickness, durability, plant-based sustainability, and added botanical soothing. They are the better all-around wipe for daily use across messy situations.
For most families, either will work well. If you are tracking diaper changes to monitor your baby's output — which is especially helpful in the first few months — tinylog makes it simple to log every change and share patterns with your pediatrician.
Related Guides
- Baby Diaper Rash — Causes, treatment, and when to call your doctor
- Baby Constipation — What's normal and when to worry
- Pampers Swaddlers vs. Huggies Little Snugglers — The two best-selling diapers compared
- Baby Feeding Chart — How much your baby should eat by age
Sources
- WaterWipes.com. "WaterWipes Original Baby Wipes — Product Information and Ingredients." 2026.
- Honest.com. "Honest Company Baby Wipes — Product Information." 2026.
- National Eczema Association. "Accepted Products Directory." nationaleczema.org, 2026.
- EPA Safer Choice. "Safer Choice Product List." epa.gov, 2026.
- BabyGearLab. "Best Baby Wipes of 2026." babygearlab.com, 2026.
- Consumer Reports. "Best Baby Wipes From Our Tests." consumerreports.org, 2026.
- Mommyhood101. "WaterWipes Review — Tested and Reviewed." mommyhood101.com, 2025.
This guide is for informational purposes only. Baby wipe choice is a personal preference based on your baby's individual skin needs. If your baby develops persistent rash or irritation with any wipe brand, consult your pediatrician.