GUIDE
Tubby Todd All Over Ointment vs. Earth Mama Organic Baby Lotion
Tubby Todd All Over Ointment is a thick, multi-purpose balm that works well for dry patches, eczema-prone skin, and mild rashes. Earth Mama Organic Baby Lotion is a lightweight, USDA-certified organic lotion designed for everyday full-body moisturizing. Tubby Todd is the heavier-duty option; Earth Mama is the gentler daily staple.
These two products approach baby skincare from different angles. Tubby Todd is a concentrated ointment that creates a protective barrier on problem areas. Earth Mama is a light, spreadable lotion meant for head-to-toe hydration after bath time. Choosing between them depends on what your baby's skin actually needs — targeted relief or everyday moisture.
An Ointment and a Lotion Walk Into a Bathroom
Tubby Todd All Over Ointment and Earth Mama Organic Baby Lotion are both popular picks in the natural baby skincare space — but they are not the same type of product. Comparing them head to head is a bit like comparing a winter coat to a light sweater. Both keep you warm, but they are built for different conditions.
Tubby Todd All Over Ointment is a thick, concentrated balm. You scoop a small amount, warm it between your fingers, and apply it to problem areas — dry patches behind the ears, rough elbows, cradle cap, irritated neck folds. It sits on top of the skin and creates a protective barrier that holds moisture in for hours.
Earth Mama Organic Baby Lotion is a lightweight, pumpable lotion. You squeeze it out, spread it over your baby's entire body after a bath, and it absorbs quickly. It hydrates and soothes without leaving a heavy film.
The real question is not which one is "better" — it is which one your baby's skin actually needs right now.
| Feature | Tubby Todd All Over Ointment | Earth Mama Organic Baby Lotion | What It Means |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brand | Tubby Todd (founded 2014, Utah-based) | Earth Mama (founded 2002, Oregon-based) | Both are independent, parent-founded brands. Earth Mama has been around longer and has a wider product line. |
| Product type | Thick, balm-like ointment | Lightweight, pourable lotion | Fundamentally different textures. Tubby Todd is concentrated and heavy; Earth Mama is light and spreadable. |
| Primary use | Targeted dry patches, eczema-prone areas, mild rashes | Full-body daily moisturizing | Tubby Todd is a spot treatment and barrier. Earth Mama is an everyday, all-over moisturizer. |
| Key ingredients | Shea butter, coconut oil, rosehip oil, lavender, beeswax | Organic calendula, colloidal oatmeal, organic olive oil, organic shea butter | Both use plant-based ingredients. Earth Mama carries USDA Organic certification; Tubby Todd does not. |
| Organic certification | Not certified organic | USDA Certified Organic | Earth Mama wins if organic certification matters to you. Tubby Todd uses natural ingredients but lacks the certification. |
| Fragrance | Light natural scent from essential oils (lavender) | Light natural scent from plant extracts (calendula, vanilla) | Both have subtle, natural scents. Neither uses synthetic fragrance. Sensitivity varies by baby. |
| Texture and application | Thick and waxy — scoop and warm between fingers before applying | Thin and smooth — pump and spread easily over large areas | Earth Mama is faster to apply head-to-toe. Tubby Todd takes more effort but creates a stronger barrier. |
| Barrier protection | Strong — ointment sits on top of skin and locks in moisture | Mild — lotion absorbs into skin quickly | Tubby Todd provides a heavier protective layer. Earth Mama hydrates but does not seal the skin the same way. |
| Common allergens | Contains beeswax, coconut oil, and essential oils | Contains oat (gluten-free), shea butter, and plant oils | Both are free of parabens, sulfates, and synthetic dyes. Check individual ingredients if your baby has known allergies. |
| Pediatrician and dermatologist mentions | Widely recommended in parent communities for eczema-prone skin | Endorsed by OBs and midwives; NSF/ANSI 305 certified | Both have strong reputations. Tubby Todd is the eczema community favorite; Earth Mama is trusted by birth professionals. |
| Packaging | Jar (various sizes) | Pump bottle (8 oz) | The pump bottle is more hygienic and easier for one-handed use during bath time. The jar requires scooping. |
Texture Matters More Than You Think
The biggest practical difference between these two products is how they feel going on and what they leave behind.
Tubby Todd is thick. You have to scoop it from a jar and rub it between your palms to soften it before spreading. It goes on heavy and stays on the surface of your baby's skin. That is the point — the waxy, butter-rich formula creates a seal that traps moisture underneath. After applying it to your baby's dry cheeks or rough patches, you will feel a slight residue on your hands.
Earth Mama is thin and silky. It pumps out easily, spreads across large areas in seconds, and absorbs within a minute or two. After it soaks in, your baby's skin feels soft without any greasy or sticky layer. It is the kind of lotion you can apply to a wiggly baby post-bath without a wrestling match.
If your baby needs moisture locked in for hours — overnight, for example — the ointment texture wins. If you want something fast and light for daily use, the lotion is far more practical.
Ingredients: Both Natural, Different Standards
Both products lean heavily into plant-based formulas, but they take different paths.
Earth Mama carries the USDA Certified Organic label, which means at least 95% of its ingredients are organically sourced. The hero ingredients are organic calendula (a traditional skin-soothing herb), colloidal oatmeal (commonly recommended by dermatologists for sensitive skin), organic olive oil, and organic shea butter. The ingredient list is clean and straightforward.
Tubby Todd uses natural ingredients — shea butter, coconut oil, rosehip seed oil, lavender essential oil, and beeswax — but does not carry an organic certification. The brand emphasizes that its formula is free of parabens, phthalates, sulfates, and synthetic fragrance.
A few things worth noting:
- Beeswax in Tubby Todd is what gives it that thick, barrier-forming texture. It is a natural ingredient but is not vegan.
- Essential oils (lavender) in Tubby Todd are generally well-tolerated, but some babies with very sensitive skin may react to them.
- Colloidal oatmeal in Earth Mama is one of the few ingredients the FDA recognizes as a skin protectant. It is a strong choice for easily irritated skin.
- Coconut oil in Tubby Todd is nourishing but can be comedogenic for some babies — worth watching if your baby is prone to clogged pores or baby acne.
Neither product contains anything alarming. The choice comes down to whether organic certification matters to your family and whether your baby tolerates the specific botanicals in each formula.
tinylog tracks feedings so you can spot patterns.
Log feedings, diaper changes, and skin reactions in one place. When you are testing new skincare products, a daily log helps you connect the dots between what goes on baby's skin and how it reacts.
| Product | Typical Price | Cost Per Ounce | Monthly Estimate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tubby Todd All Over Ointment (3.5 oz jar) | $26–$30 | ~$7.50–$8.50/oz | ~$15–$30 (depends on usage) |
| Tubby Todd All Over Ointment (7 oz jar) | $42–$48 | ~$6.00–$6.85/oz | ~$15–$25 (depends on usage) |
| Earth Mama Organic Baby Lotion (8 oz pump) | $12–$16 | ~$1.50–$2.00/oz | ~$12–$20 |
Price: Earth Mama Is Significantly Cheaper Per Ounce
There is no getting around it — Tubby Todd All Over Ointment costs roughly four times more per ounce than Earth Mama Organic Baby Lotion. At $7–$8 per ounce vs. $1.50–$2.00 per ounce, the price gap is substantial.
But the per-ounce comparison does not tell the whole story. Tubby Todd is a concentrated ointment. A pea-sized amount covers a large patch of skin. Most parents find that a 3.5 oz jar lasts 4–8 weeks when used for targeted spot treatment. Earth Mama is a lotion you spread over your baby's entire body, so you go through it faster.
When you compare monthly spending based on actual usage patterns, the gap narrows:
- Earth Mama for daily full-body use: roughly $12–$20/month
- Tubby Todd for targeted spot treatment: roughly $15–$30/month
If you use Tubby Todd on your baby's entire body daily (some parents do), the cost climbs significantly. Used as intended — on specific dry or irritated areas — the monthly cost is more manageable.
Ways to save on Tubby Todd:
- Buy the larger 7 oz jar — the per-ounce price drops by about 15–20%
- Subscribe on the Tubby Todd website for recurring delivery discounts
- Watch for seasonal bundles that include ointment plus other products at a discount
When an Ointment Is the Right Call
Ointments and lotions are not interchangeable. There are real situations where the heavier product is what your baby's skin needs:
- Dry patches that reappear hours after applying lotion. If you moisturize and the rough spot is back by bedtime, your baby's skin is losing moisture faster than the lotion can replenish it. An ointment traps moisture underneath and slows that loss.
- Cracking or flaking skin. Visible flaking on cheeks, behind the ears, or on the scalp needs a barrier, not just hydration. The ointment's wax-based formula protects the healing skin underneath.
- Winter months and dry climates. Cold, dry air strips moisture from baby skin quickly. An ointment layer before going outside acts as a wind and cold barrier.
- Eczema-prone areas. While not a medical treatment, many parents find that Tubby Todd helps manage mild eczema flare-ups by keeping affected areas sealed and hydrated between prescription treatments.
If your baby's skin looks and feels healthy most of the time, a lotion is probably all you need. Reach for the ointment when the lotion is not cutting it.
Choose Tubby Todd All Over Ointment If
- Your baby has dry patches, rough spots, or eczema-prone skin that needs targeted treatment
- You want a thick barrier ointment that locks moisture in overnight
- You have tried lightweight lotions and they are not providing enough relief
- You need a multi-purpose balm for cradle cap, dry cheeks, chapped lips, or irritated creases
- You prefer a concentrated product where a small amount covers a lot of ground
Choose Earth Mama Organic Baby Lotion If
- You want a gentle daily moisturizer for full-body use after baths
- Organic certification is a priority for your family
- Your baby has generally healthy skin that just needs routine hydration
- You prefer a lightweight lotion that absorbs quickly and does not leave a greasy residue
- Budget matters — you want a quality natural lotion at a reasonable price per ounce
- You want pump-bottle convenience for fast, one-handed application during squirmy bath time
Where to Buy
If your baby has dry patches, rough spots, or eczema-prone skin that needs more than a basic lotion, Tubby Todd All Over Ointment (~$28 for 3.5 oz) is the product parents rave about for a reason. A small scoop goes a long way, and the thick barrier formula keeps problem areas hydrated for hours. The 7 oz jar is the better value if you know your baby's skin responds well to it.
If you want a gentle, certified-organic daily moisturizer for routine post-bath hydration, Earth Mama Organic Baby Lotion (~$14 for 8 oz) is a reliable everyday choice. The calendula and oatmeal formula is soothing, the pump bottle is practical, and the price is fair for a USDA-certified organic product.
Our honest take: most families benefit from having both types of product — a daily lotion for routine moisture and a heavier ointment for when trouble spots appear. They solve different problems and work well together.
tinylog earns a small commission on purchases made through these links, at no cost to you.
The Bottom Line
Tubby Todd All Over Ointment and Earth Mama Organic Baby Lotion are both quality products from trusted brands — but they fill different roles in your baby's skincare routine.
Tubby Todd is the heavy hitter. Thick, concentrated, and designed to create a lasting barrier on dry, irritated, or eczema-prone skin. It costs more per ounce but goes further per application. It is the product you reach for when your baby's skin is struggling.
Earth Mama is the daily staple. Lightweight, organic, and easy to apply head-to-toe after bath time. It keeps healthy skin soft and hydrated without the heaviness of an ointment. It is more affordable and practical for everyday use.
For babies with generally healthy skin, Earth Mama is a great starting point. For babies who need more intensive moisture support, Tubby Todd is worth the investment. And for many families, keeping both on hand covers all the bases.
If you are testing new products on your baby's skin, tracking feedings and skin changes together in tinylog can help you spot patterns — like whether a new lotion triggers fussiness or a rash shows up on feeding days versus off days.
Sources
- TubbyTodd.com. "All Over Ointment — Ingredient Information and Usage Guide." 2026.
- EarthMamaOrganics.com. "Organic Baby Lotion — Product Details." 2026.
- USDA. "Organic Labeling Standards." usda.gov.
- National Eczema Association. "Moisturizers and Emollients for Eczema." nationaleczema.org.
- American Academy of Dermatology. "How to Care for Your Baby's Skin." aad.org.
- Healthline Parenthood. "Best Organic Baby Lotions." healthline.com, 2026.
- BabyCenter. "Baby Skin Care Basics." babycenter.com, 2026.
This guide is for informational purposes only and is not medical advice. Every baby's skin is different. If your baby has persistent eczema, rashes, or skin irritation, consult your pediatrician or a pediatric dermatologist before choosing skincare products.