Tubby Todd All Over Ointment vs. Pipette Baby Lotion

Tubby Todd All Over Ointment and Pipette Baby Lotion both show up on "best baby skincare" lists constantly. Parents rave about both. But they are not interchangeable, and comparing them head-to-head is a little like comparing a winter coat to a T-shirt — both keep you covered, but they are built for different conditions.

Tubby Todd All Over Ointment is a thick, balm-like product packed with shea butter, jojoba oil, rosehip, and botanicals like calendula and chamomile. You scoop out a small amount and work it into problem spots — dry patches behind the ears, eczema on the cheeks, flaky cradle cap, or irritated diaper areas. It sits on the skin, creates a protective seal, and lets the oils do their work over time.

Pipette Baby Lotion is a lightweight, squalane-based moisturizer designed for daily, all-over use. You pump it out, spread it over your baby's entire body after a bath, and it absorbs in under a minute. No residue, no greasiness, no lingering scent.

The real question is not which one is "better." It is which one your baby's skin needs right now — and whether you need both.

If you have never used Tubby Todd All Over Ointment before, the texture will surprise you. It is thick — almost like a soft wax or a very dense body butter. You warm a small amount between your fingers, then press it into the skin. It does not fully absorb. That is intentional. The ointment creates an occlusive barrier that traps moisture underneath and protects irritated skin from further exposure.

Pipette Baby Lotion is the opposite experience. It is silky, light, and disappears into the skin almost immediately. You can apply it generously over your baby's arms, legs, belly, and back without any sticky or greasy aftermath. Getting a onesie on right after application is not a problem.

For everyday post-bath moisturizing, the lotion is far more practical. For treating a specific rough patch on your baby's elbow or a dry spot behind the knee, the ointment's staying power is the whole point.

Both products check the "clean beauty" boxes — no parabens, no phthalates, no synthetic fragrances, no dyes. But they take different paths to get there.

Tubby Todd leans into traditional botanicals. The ingredient list reads like an herbalist's shelf: shea butter, jojoba oil, rosehip seed oil, lavender essential oil, chamomile extract, calendula flower extract. These ingredients have long histories in skin-soothing applications. The lavender and chamomile give the ointment a very mild, natural scent.

Pipette takes a more science-forward approach. The star ingredient is squalane — a hydrocarbon that occurs naturally in human skin but is produced here from sugarcane through a biotech fermentation process. Squalane is an exceptional moisturizer because it mimics the lipids your skin already produces, making it easy to absorb and very unlikely to cause reactions. The rest of the formula includes glycerin, shea butter, and jojoba esters.

One thing to note: Tubby Todd does contain essential oils. The vast majority of babies tolerate them without issue, but some pediatric dermatologists prefer to avoid essential oils on very young or eczema-prone skin. Pipette's fragrance-free, essential-oil-free formula may be the safer bet if your baby has already shown sensitivity.

At first glance, Tubby Todd looks significantly more expensive. A 6 oz jar runs $26–$32, compared to a 6 oz bottle of Pipette lotion at $10–$13. Ounce for ounce, the ointment costs roughly three times as much.

But here is where the math gets more nuanced. You do not use ointment the same way you use lotion. A small scoop of Tubby Todd — maybe the size of a pea — covers a dry patch on your baby's cheek. One jar can last 6–10 weeks with targeted use. Meanwhile, you are pumping out a palmful of Pipette lotion every single bath time to cover your baby's whole body. A 6 oz bottle of lotion might last 3–4 weeks.

When you factor in actual usage patterns, the monthly cost gap narrows considerably. Many families spend $13–$22/month on Tubby Todd (one jar every 6–10 weeks) and $10–$18/month on Pipette (one bottle every 3–5 weeks).

If budget is tight and you can only pick one, Pipette gives you the broader daily coverage at a lower price point. If your baby has specific problem areas that need attention, the Tubby Todd ointment may save you money on prescription creams down the road.

The most helpful way to think about these two products is not as competitors but as teammates in a skincare lineup.

Use Pipette Baby Lotion when:

• You are doing a regular post-bath moisturizing routine
• Your baby's skin is generally healthy and just needs daily hydration
• You want quick-absorbing moisture that will not transfer to clothes or bedding
• You are applying product head to toe

Use Tubby Todd All Over Ointment when:

• Your baby has a dry, rough, or flaky patch that is not responding to regular lotion
• Eczema is flaring on cheeks, elbows, or behind the knees
• Cradle cap needs to be softened before gentle combing
• Diaper rash is developing and you want an extra barrier
• Winter weather or dry air has left your baby's skin cracked or irritated

Many parents keep both on the changing table — lotion for the routine, ointment for the rescue work.

If your baby's skin needs targeted repair work, Tubby Todd All Over Ointment (~$28 for 6 oz) is the product parents reach for when regular lotion is not cutting it. The thick, botanical-rich formula is beloved for tackling dry patches, eczema spots, and cradle cap. A little goes a long way, so one jar lasts longer than you would expect.

If you need a reliable daily moisturizer for healthy skin maintenance, Pipette Baby Lotion (~$14 for 12 oz) is a lightweight, squalane-based lotion that absorbs fast, leaves no greasy residue, and carries EWG Verified status. It is an excellent everyday staple at a very reasonable price.

Our honest take: if you can keep both on hand, that is the best setup. Pipette handles the daily routine. Tubby Todd handles the flare-ups. Your baby's skin will thank you either way.

tinylog earns a small commission on purchases made through these links, at no cost to you.

Tubby Todd All Over Ointment and Pipette Baby Lotion are both high-quality baby skincare products — but they fill different roles.

Tubby Todd is the heavy hitter. Thick, protective, and packed with botanical oils, it excels at treating dry patches, eczema, cradle cap, and irritated skin. It costs more per ounce but is used sparingly on targeted areas.

Pipette is the daily workhorse. Lightweight, fragrance-free, and fast-absorbing, it keeps your baby's skin hydrated from head to toe without fuss. It costs less, absorbs faster, and works beautifully as a post-bath routine.

For babies with persistent dry or irritated skin, Tubby Todd is hard to beat. For everyday hydration with a clean, simple formula, Pipette is a standout. And for parents who want both bases covered — grab one of each.

If you are tracking feedings and want to note how your baby's skin responds to new products, tinylog makes it easy to log patterns and share them with your pediatrician.

• TubbyTodd.com. "All Over Ointment — Ingredients and Product Information." 2026.
• Pipettebaby.com. "Baby Lotion — Ingredients and Product Information." 2026.
• Environmental Working Group. "EWG Verified: Pipette Baby Lotion." ewg.org.
• American Academy of Dermatology. "How to Care for Your Baby's Skin." aad.org.
• Healthline Parenthood. "Best Baby Lotions and Moisturizers." healthline.com, 2026.
• National Eczema Association. "Eczema and Bathing." nationaleczema.org.
• WhatToExpect.com. "Best Baby Lotions of 2026." whattoexpect.com.

This guide is for informational purposes only and is not medical advice. Every baby's skin is different. If your baby has persistent eczema, rashes, or skin irritation, consult your pediatrician or a pediatric dermatologist before starting any new skincare product.