GUIDE
Frida Baby Get-A-Grip vs. Infantino Water Teethers
The Frida Baby Get-A-Grip is a textured silicone teether designed so babies can hold it themselves from around three months. The Infantino Water Teethers are water-filled and meant to be chilled in the fridge for cold soothing relief. Both are affordable, BPA-free, and well-reviewed — but they take very different approaches to teething comfort.
Frida Baby built the Get-A-Grip around one idea: let the baby hold the teether without help. Its unique shape and soft silicone nubs make it easy for tiny hands to grasp and bring to the mouth independently. Infantino's Water Teethers take a different route — they are filled with purified water that stays cool after refrigeration, giving sore gums a cold compress effect. Both are budget-friendly, free of harmful chemicals, and popular on Amazon. The right pick depends on whether your baby needs textured chewing surfaces or cold relief.
Free trial • Log feeds, naps, and teething symptoms
Two Popular Teethers, Two Very Different Approaches
Teething is one of those phases that every parent dreads a little. Your baby is uncomfortable, drooling everywhere, chewing on anything within reach, and sometimes refusing to eat. A good teether can make a real difference — but the sheer number of options on the shelf makes choosing one harder than it should be.
The Frida Baby Get-A-Grip and Infantino Water Teethers are two of the most popular picks on Amazon, and they could not be more different in how they work. One is a textured silicone teether built around easy grip. The other is a water-filled chilling teether designed to numb sore gums with cold.
We broke down the materials, soothing method, ease of cleaning, safety, and real parent feedback so you can figure out which one belongs in your diaper bag — or whether you might want both.
For more on teething timelines and what to expect, check out our baby teething chart.
| Feature | Frida Baby Get-A-Grip | Infantino Water Teethers | What It Means |
|---|---|---|---|
| Teether type | Textured silicone teether | Water-filled teether (set of multiple keys) | Different approaches. Frida Baby focuses on texture and grip. Infantino focuses on cold relief. |
| Soothing method | Textured nubs and ridges for counter-pressure on gums | Chilled water inside provides cold soothing after refrigeration | If your baby responds to cold, Infantino wins. If texture and chewing are enough, Frida Baby delivers. |
| Grip and hold | Specifically designed so babies can grab and hold it unassisted from 3 months | Key-ring shape with multiple teething keys — easy to grab but bulkier | Frida Baby was engineered around self-grip. It is noticeably easier for small hands to hold independently. |
| Material | 100% food-grade silicone | BPA-free plastic shell with purified water fill | Silicone is generally more durable and easier to sterilize. Both materials are safe. |
| Recommended age | 3 months and up | 3 months and up | Tie. Both are safe from three months, though younger babies may find the Frida Baby easier to manage. |
| Refrigeration needed | No — works at room temperature (can be chilled but not required) | Yes — designed to be refrigerated for 30 minutes before use | Frida Baby is grab-and-go. Infantino requires planning ahead to chill. |
| Cleaning | Dishwasher safe, boilable, steam sterilizer safe | Hand wash with warm soapy water only — no dishwasher, no boiling | Frida Baby is far easier to clean thoroughly. The water-filled design limits Infantino's cleaning options. |
| Durability | Solid silicone — very durable, no parts to break or leak | Water-filled chamber can develop leaks with heavy use over time | Frida Baby wins on longevity. Silicone holds up better than a water-filled plastic shell. |
| Portability | Lightweight and compact — easy to toss in a diaper bag | Bulkier key-ring shape; needs a cooler bag to stay cold on the go | Frida Baby is more portable. Infantino loses its cold benefit without refrigeration access. |
| Number included | 1 teether per package | Set of 2 to 4 teething keys per package (varies by set) | Infantino gives you more pieces per purchase. Helpful for rotating or keeping one in the fridge. |
| Choking hazard design | One-piece construction with no small parts | Connected key-ring design with no detachable small parts | Both are designed to prevent choking. Frida Baby's single-piece design has a slight safety edge. |
How They Soothe: Texture vs. Cold
This is the core difference between these two teethers, and it matters more than you might think.
Frida Baby Get-A-Grip uses textured silicone nubs and ridges to provide counter-pressure when your baby bites down. The idea is similar to rubbing your baby's gums with your finger — the pressure itself offers relief. It works at room temperature, so there is no prep involved. Just hand it to your baby and let them go to town.
Infantino Water Teethers take the opposite approach. The teething keys are filled with purified water that retains cold after about 30 minutes in the fridge. When your baby chews on them, the cool surface helps numb inflamed gums and reduce swelling. Think of it like a tiny ice pack for the mouth.
Some babies strongly prefer one method over the other. If your little one has been rubbing their gums on everything from your knuckle to the coffee table, a textured teether like the Get-A-Grip may be the right fit. If they seem most relieved after chewing on a cold washcloth, the Infantino set is worth trying.
Grip and Independence
One thing that sets the Frida Baby Get-A-Grip apart is right there in the name — the grip.
The teether was designed from the ground up so that babies as young as three months can grab it, hold it, and bring it to their mouths without a parent's help. The shape fits naturally in a small hand, and the silicone surface is slightly tacky, which keeps it from slipping. Parents consistently note in reviews that their babies could hold it independently earlier than other teethers they had tried.
The Infantino Water Teethers use a key-ring shape that is familiar and easy enough for most babies to grab. But the set is a bit bulkier and heavier (water adds weight), so very young babies sometimes need help holding it in position. By five or six months, most babies handle it fine on their own.
If your baby is on the younger side and you want them to self-soothe with a teether, the Frida Baby design has a clear advantage here.
tinylog tracks feedings so you can spot patterns.
Log breastfeeding, bottles, solids, and teething symptoms. See whether your baby's eating less during teething flares. Bring the data to your next well-visit.
Cleaning and Maintenance
This is an area where silicone teethers have a meaningful advantage over water-filled ones.
The Frida Baby Get-A-Grip is made of a single piece of food-grade silicone. You can wash it with soap and water, toss it in the top rack of the dishwasher, boil it for five minutes, or throw it in a steam sterilizer. It handles all of it without breaking down. That flexibility is especially helpful during cold and flu season or if your baby drops the teether on the floor at a restaurant (which they will).
The Infantino Water Teethers need a gentler touch. Because they are filled with water, you cannot boil them or put them in a dishwasher or sterilizer — the heat would compromise the sealed chamber and potentially cause leaks. Hand washing with warm soapy water is the only recommended method. That is perfectly fine for day-to-day use, but you lose the ability to truly sterilize them.
If hygiene and ease of deep cleaning are high on your list, the Frida Baby teether is the more practical choice.
Safety and Durability
Both teethers meet current CPSC safety standards and are free of BPA, PVC, and phthalates. Neither contains latex. Both are designed to be too large for a baby to choke on.
Where they differ is long-term durability.
Frida Baby's solid silicone construction means there is nothing inside that can leak, break, or degrade. Silicone is naturally resistant to bacteria growth, does not absorb odors, and holds up well under repeated sterilization. Parents report these teethers lasting through multiple children.
Infantino Water Teethers are durable for their price point, but the water-filled design introduces a potential failure point. Heavy chewers can eventually puncture the plastic, and the sealed chambers can develop slow leaks over months of use. The water inside is purified and non-toxic, so a leak is not dangerous, but it does mean the teether needs to be replaced once it starts. For a $5–$9 set, that is a fair trade-off.
Inspect any teether regularly — especially water-filled ones — for cracks, discoloration, or signs of wear. Replace immediately if you notice damage.
| Product | Typical Price | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Frida Baby Get-A-Grip Teether | $8–$11 | Single teether. Often bundled in Frida Baby teething kits at a slight discount. |
| Infantino Water Teethers (multi-key set) | $5–$9 | Includes 2 to 4 teething keys depending on the set. Among the lowest-priced teethers available. |
| Frida Baby Teething Relief Kit (bundle) | $18–$24 | Includes Get-A-Grip teether plus finger toothbrush, gum gel, and carrying case. |
Price: Both Are Budget-Friendly
Neither of these teethers will strain your wallet, which is one reason both are so popular.
The Infantino Water Teethers are among the most affordable teething products you can buy. At $5–$9 for a set of multiple keys, you are paying just a couple of dollars per teething piece. That makes it easy to buy two sets — one for home and one for the diaper bag — without thinking twice.
The Frida Baby Get-A-Grip is a bit pricier at $8–$11 for a single teether, but you are paying for solid silicone construction, sterilization flexibility, and a more durable product overall. The Frida Baby Teething Relief Kit bundled with a finger toothbrush and gum gel runs around $18–$24 and is decent value if you want the full teething toolkit.
Both teethers fall well below the $15–$30 range you will see for premium silicone teethers from brands like Comotomo or Sophie la Girafe. For parents who want reliable soothing without the premium price tag, either option delivers.
Choose the Frida Baby Get-A-Grip If
- Your baby is young (3 to 5 months) and still developing their grip — the self-grip design helps them hold it independently
- You want a teether you can sterilize easily by boiling or running through the dishwasher
- Portability matters — you need something lightweight for the diaper bag without worrying about keeping it cold
- You prefer a one-piece silicone construction with no risk of leaking
- Your baby responds well to textured chewing surfaces rather than cold temperatures
Choose the Infantino Water Teethers If
- Your baby gets noticeable relief from cold items on their gums
- You want multiple teething pieces in a single affordable package
- Your baby is in an intense teething phase with several teeth coming in at once
- You are mostly at home and have easy access to a refrigerator
- Budget is a top priority — Infantino is one of the most affordable teethers on the market
- Your baby likes holding key-shaped toys and bringing them to their mouth
Where to Buy
The Frida Baby Get-A-Grip Teether ($8–$11) is a well-designed silicone teether that babies can actually hold on their own. Lightweight, sterilizable, and built to last. A solid everyday teether that travels well and requires zero prep.
The Infantino Water Teethers ($5–$9 for a multi-key set) offer cold soothing relief at one of the lowest price points in the teether category. Pop them in the fridge for 30 minutes and hand them over when your baby needs comfort. Great for intense teething phases.
Plenty of parents end up owning both — using the Frida Baby for on-the-go and the Infantino set at home where the fridge is handy. They complement each other well and together cost less than a single premium teether.
tinylog earns a small commission on purchases made through these links, at no cost to you.
The Bottom Line
The Frida Baby Get-A-Grip and Infantino Water Teethers are both effective, affordable teethers — they just solve the teething problem differently.
Frida Baby is the better all-around pick for everyday use. The self-grip design, solid silicone construction, easy sterilization, and grab-and-go portability make it a reliable choice from the earliest teething days through the toddler years. It does not need refrigeration, it does not leak, and it survives being boiled, dropped, and chewed on relentlessly.
Infantino is the better pick when your baby is in real discomfort and cold is what works. The chilled water-filled keys offer a kind of soothing that no room-temperature teether can match. At under $9 for a multi-piece set, you get cold relief for less than the price of a coffee.
If you are only buying one, the Frida Baby Get-A-Grip is the more versatile choice. If your baby is deep in a painful teething stretch and loves cold things, add the Infantino set to your cart too. Together, they cover both angles of teething relief for under $20.
If you are tracking your baby's feedings and notice they are eating less or fussing more around certain times, tinylog can help you log those patterns and bring useful data to your pediatrician.
Sources
- Frida Baby. "Get-A-Grip Teether — Product Information." fridababy.com, 2026.
- Infantino. "Water Teethers — Product Details." infantino.com, 2026.
- Amazon.com. "Frida Baby Get-A-Grip Teether — Customer Reviews." 2025–2026.
- Amazon.com. "Infantino Water Teethers — Customer Reviews." 2025–2026.
- American Academy of Pediatrics. "Teething: 4 to 7 Months." healthychildren.org, 2024.
- FDA. "Safely Soothing Teething Pain and Sensory Needs in Babies and Older Children." fda.gov, 2023.
- BabyGearLab. "Best Baby Teethers, Tested & Ranked." babygearlab.com, 2026.
This guide is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Teether choice is a personal decision based on your baby's preferences and needs. Always supervise your baby during teether use. Consult your pediatrician if you have concerns about teething pain or feeding changes.